Post-Trash Facebook Post-Trash Twitter

Chastity Belt - "All My Friends" | Album Review

by Patrick Daul (@patrickdaul425)

As bands age and the lives of their members change, the motivations propelling everything forward aren’t as easy to pin down. The age-old rock band enemies like financial instability and immaturity might still kick around, but changes in scenery and circumstance lead to tough (even existential) questions for even the most driven artists. It doesn’t feel so long ago when Chastity Belt bubbled up out of the Washington town of Walla Walla to land in the center of the indie rock world, and yet the project is back with their sixth full-length release. All My Friends finds the band regrouping amidst shifting goalposts for how they measure success, and for the first time, looking back. 

Firmly out of their nascent stage propelled by buzzy reviews from the day's tastemakers, Chastity Belt have become intermittent but reliable figures in indie rock’s increasingly disjointed big tent. The outfit aren’t exactly elder statesmen or even household names, but there’s a quiet authority with which they craft and deliver forlorn pop rock informed as much by Slowdive and Sleater-Kinney as early 2000s Top 40. After years away, frontwoman Julia Shapiro returned from London to work on the project. 

Despite the album’s material being written and recorded in their hometown of Seattle, there’s a bucolic tinge to All My Friends. It really does sound like they rented a cottage in some remote corner of Cascadia to pool their ideas together. For much of the record, acoustic strumming replaces the fuzz and jangle of I Used to Spend So Much Time Alone and Time to Go Home. There’s a home-y, lived-in feel to these songs. It must be noted that the production is nothing less than crisp, and the listener is given enough space to appreciate free-flowing arrangements and inventive percussion. This is the most musical Chastity Belt has sounded yet. 

The internet has largely evened out the regional differences of music scenes, but how much of a Seattle band Chastity Belt is might be an underappreciated facet of their mystique. Even more impressive is that they've cultivated this aura with minimal flannel use. They broke through on Sub Pop imprint Hardly Art and are now tentpole features for the always-excellent Suicide Squeeze label. Chastity Belt’s concise discography feels very much in the tradition of Pacific Northwest indie rock that came before it, even if they fall into the hyper-online blog rock scene of the late 2010s. The band doesn’t telegraph its influences explicitly, yet they fuse regionally apt grunge textures with Built to Spill and Death Cab-esque songcraft. 

They’ve steadily built on their strengths while avoiding entrenching themselves in their signature sound. But it wouldn’t be a Chastity Belt record without some deftly interwoven fretwork, showcased notably on the autumnal “Live Laugh Love” (curiously the name of their previous record). Even if their guitar riffs keep an edge, there is so much heartache in the playing that you won’t need to pore over lyrics to interpret the emotions behind these songs. The math-y guitar passages on “I Could Say Less” would appeal to American Football fans and set the stage for some of Shapiro’s most emotive singing. Few, if any, groups capture the feeling of bittersweetness quite like Chastity Belt. 

A decade-plus of touring and looking at the news have stripped away the snark that lent a playfulness to their earlier work. What’s left is something genuine rather than jaded. This is most apparent with Shapiro, as these are her most vulnerable vocals yet. Her signature shouts and howls are still there, but the breathy delivery on “To Decide” is more affecting. The haunting mantra of “Friends For This” repeatedly implores the listener to always tell your friends the truth. This is just one of many moments hinting at a group collectively working through some things. 

The band has spread its footprint across multiple cities, and even continents, but a creative rekindling has brought forth some of their strongest work to date. More than previous efforts, the material benefits heavily from a collaborative process. The “boys” are back in town, but don’t expect any Thin Lizzy belters on this record. Chastity Belt rarely traffics in that sort of raucous energy, no matter how stoked they are to be playing tunes with each other again. The point of All My Friends isn’t to raise the stakes for the band or explore some new genre. It turns out making music with your friends for the sake of it can yield fantastic results, but something tells me the members of Chastity Belt aren’t keeping score.